🎙️ A For-Profit Company Taxed Like a Church: Kelly Finnell Explains the S Corp ESOP
Kelly Finnell was a first-year law student in 1979 when a room of pension lawyers handed "the kid" a research assignment on ESOPs. That one summer became a 45-year career. Today he is the founder and president of EFS ESOP Consultants, a firm that works only on ESOPs and helps business owners sell their companies to their own employees.
Kelly explains how an ESOP works in plain business owner language, from how the deal gets funded to the tax benefits most owners have never heard of. He shares why his firm turns away owners who don't ask what's in it for their employees, and what it was like to go all in on ESOPs in the summer of 2008, months before Lehman Brothers collapsed. He also tells how a year and a half of slow business produced his book, The ESOP Coach, which advisors now use to train their teams.
✨ Key Insights You'll Learn:
Why an ESOP is both an exit for the owner and a retirement plan for employees
The three rules that set an ESOP apart from a 401(k)
How a bank loan and seller notes fund the owner's buyout
Who qualifies to participate and how payouts work when employees leave
How Section 1042 lets an owner sell to an ESOP and defer the tax
Why a 100% ESOP-owned S corporation pays no income tax
The minimums: about $2 million in adjusted EBITDA, 35 employees and a strong successor team
Why ESOP deals rarely fall apart before closing, unlike most third-party sales
The repurchase obligation and why smart ESOP companies build a sinking fund
How AI is speeding up ESOP feasibility studies, and the part it still gets wrong
🌟 Kelly's Key Mentors:
Jerry: a Chicago ESOP lawyer, known as the leading ESOP expert, who taught Kelly to explain complex ideas simply
His father: encouraged him for years to write a book
Alan: his former partner, who bought the non-ESOP side of the business and freed Kelly to go all in
His wife, Beverly: trusted his decision to change course
👉 Don't miss this conversation about helping owners cash in on their life's work while taking care of the people who helped them build it.
Listen to the full episode here
Transcript
The 1979 ESOP Research Assignment
Anthony Codispoti (00:00)
Welcome to another edition of the Inspired Stories Podcast, where leaders share their experiences so we can learn from their successes and be inspired by how they've overcome adversity. As you listen today, let one idea shape what you do next. My name is Anthony Codispoti, and today's guest was a first-year law student in 1979 when a Massachusetts law firm handed him a research assignment on employee stock ownership plans, or ESOPs.
Now, an ASOP lets a business owner sell the company to its own employees through a retirement plan. He has since built his entire career around that one idea. In 1981, the same year he finished law school, he opened his own firm in Memphis. In 2010, he published the Aesop Coach, a guide for owners planning their exit. Then in 2022, to cite just one of many examples, his firm helped a restaurant group with more than 325 employees.
Become employee owned. He has also assisted many, many other companies through the process. Kelly Finnell is the founder and president of EFS ESOP Consultants, a national firm that works only on ESOPs and ownership succession. His firm's largest transaction was valued at $280 million, and he has presented on eSOPs at more than 300 conferences from Memphis to London to Sydney.
But before we get into all that good stuff, today's episode is brought to you by my company, AddBack Benefits Agency. And if you advise business owners planning their exit or succession, this is a lever most of your clients don't know they have. See, here's the problem: your business owner clients are overspending on health insurance every year. That's money leaking out of the business. Money that could be funding the very strategies you're building with them.
Now there's a program from Bain Capital Insurance you can put in front of them to change all that. It doesn't replace their group health plan. It fills in the first dollar gaps and can even cover part-timers. Employees get unlimited access to doctors, therapists, and prescriptions with no co-pays or deductibles to meet. And here's why it matters for your practice. This program actually increases your client's net profits. We recently helped a client add.
That's add $900 per employee per year to their bottom line. Results vary, but gains like that free up cash to fund the transition and raise the value of the business itself. Your client's company gets stronger and more valuable. You become the advisor who found the money and the one they tell their friends about. Learn more at AddBackBenefits.com. All right, back to our guest today, the president of EFS ESOP
Kelly Finnell (02:48)
Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (02:49)
Consultants, Kelly Pinnell. Thanks for making the time to share your story today.
Kelly Finnell (02:53)
Well, thanks for inviting me. I really look forward to the conversation.
Anthony Codispoti (02:57)
All right, well let's jump in. So in nineteen seventy-nine, you're a first year law student and a Massachusetts law firm asked you to research ESOPs for a white paper. What was the firm trying to find out? I mean, ESOPs had only been in the tax code for five years since seventy-four, when you took
Kelly Finnell (03:16)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (03:16)
that assignment. So what do you remember thinking as you were learning about this structure?
Kelly Finnell (03:20)
Well, the project was initiated by a letter that they received from one of their clients in New Orleans. I I still remember the specifics. I remember the name of the client to this day. And he asked for a white paper on ESOPs. And I'm in this room with a lot of experienced pension lawyers, and they all looked at each other and said,
We don't know anything about ESOPs. You know, as you said, it's only been in the code for five years. Let's give this assignment to the kid. And in nineteen seventy-nine, I was the kid. And my first reaction was, this is gonna be the longest summer of my life having to research and write a paper about this arcane subject. But it turned in
To one of the best experiences I've ever had, and it is the reason that I've been in this business now for over forty five years.
Anthony Codispoti (04:23)
So back in 1979, what did that research process look like? There's no AI, there's no Google, there's no internet.
Kelly Finnell (04:31)
Well, it was um almost a dungeon like experience. they had a library in the basement of the building, no windows, just a bunch of old dusty, moldy law books, and so I spent much of the summer down there uh in this very uninviting atmosphere, uh reading and writing.
Anthony Codispoti (05:00)
Now you're saying that you're around these old dusty law books, but this was a relatively new thing, right? So this isn't gonna show up in the old law books. How are you getting access to, I don't know, newer parts of the code?
Kelly Finnell (05:13)
Well, the books were there. Um, not all of the books were old. Uh the ones that um incorporated Orissa, which was only five years old, were new, but this was a huge law library. Uh I mean it uh could have been a acre full of books.
Anthony Codispoti (05:33)
Wow.
Kelly Finnell (05:33)
And so uh it was the other books that you know had been there for a while and many of them hadn't been pulled off the shelf in years.
And so it was just a very interesting experience that I would have bet a thousand dollars, which I didn't have at that time, that it was just going to be a terrible experience. But it was one of those things where uh lemons were turned into lemonade. It was something that I I I thought was going to be miserable, and it turned out to be the
Best thing that's ever happened for me.
Anthony Codispoti (06:10)
How far into your research process were you before that switch took place?
Kelly Finnell (06:16)
Yeah, I don't know if it took place then, Anthony. It might have actually taken place later when I started building the business on what I had learned then, but I knew immediately that I love the concept of shared capitalism and allowing owners when they cash in on their life's work to be able to reward the people and protect the people.
That had helped them build the business that they were going to sell. So if you sell to a third party, to private equity, or to a strategic buyer, you're exposing your employees to an unknown risk. Certainly the company culture is going to change. um And perhaps in order to pay the owner, there are going to be reductions in force.
And I loved the idea of eliminating those risks for employees and in fact having a structure where they benefit rather than potentially suffer. And before that, I had never been in the bus uh business building as an undergraduate in college. And so I went back to law school knowing that this was the business that I wanted to be in.
and had to make up for lost ground and take every business uh oriented course I could the next two years of law school.
Anthony Codispoti (07:52)
Because you already had a sense that this is the direction you wanted to take your career.
Kelly Finnell (07:56)
Absolutely.
Anthony Codispoti (07:57)
So walk me through how the eSOP structure works. The big idea is, like you were saying, this is an opportunity for an owner to exit, but not put the employees in the company at risk of what a private equity firm might do to it.
How an ESOP Works
Kelly Finnell (08:13)
Right.
Yes, so an ESOP is really three things in one. For a business owner, it's a liquidity strategy and an alternative to selling to private equity or to a strategic buyer. For the company's employees, an ESOP is a retirement plan. So I often describe it as being a first cousin.
To a 401k plan. And about 80% of the rules that apply to 401k plans are the same rules that apply to ESOPs. But there are three rules that are different that make this ESOP serve these dual purposes of being a liquidity strategy for the owner and a retirement plan for the employee. The first key difference is that an ESOP can borrow money.
Every other type of retirement plan is specifically prohibited from doing that. The second difference is that an ESOP is required to invest primarily in the stock of the sponsoring employer. And the third difference is that an ESOP can engage in certain transactions with parties in interest. So if you put those three things together, what's going on behind the scenes and how the ESOP is working.
Is that the ESOP can borrow money? And so that money usually comes from two sources. There is a bank loan that finances a part of the ESOP's purchase. And then there are seller notes, which is an IOU issued by the company to the selling shareholder. And that IOU is going to pay interest only while the bank debt is being retired. And then will either be amortized.
By the company after the bank debt is retired or will be refinanced with additional bank debt. And so those are the sources of capital that are going to fund the ESOP. And once the ESOP has purchased the owner's stock, then it becomes a retirement plan in over a period of years. That might be 20 to 40 years typically.
Shares are going to be divided up or allocated among the company's uh ESOP participants. So substantially all of the company's employees are going to participate in this plan and they're going to have shares contributed to their account, their ESOP account, over a period of 20 to 40 years.
Anthony Codispoti (10:54)
So let's take an example of say a restaurant group. Um, you've got management, you've got your frontline folks. Are the frontline folks participating in this as well? Because this tends to be like a higher turnover kind of position. They're not gonna be there twenty to forty years.
Kelly Finnell (11:13)
Yeah, y you're you're right in many instances. But uh those employees will participate if they satisfy uh the plans requirements for participation, which are dictated by the Internal Revenue Code. And so those requirements are first uh only full time employees can participate.
In full time is defined as a 12-month period during which the employee works at least 1,000 hours. And so if you have a server or a bartender that only works on the weekends, they're not going to satisfy that 1,000-hour requirement and they're not going to be a participant in the ESOM. Certainly, all of that management group.
Is going to satisfy that requirement. In some of the uh professional service servers, people that are doing this not as college students, but uh as a career and are working this as a full-time job, those folks will participate. And hopefully the ESOP will reduce the company's turnover rate because these people are able to participate.
In a retirement plan that they can't get at any other restaurant job. There are so few restaurants that offer a benefit like this uh that those that are thinking a little longer term, they're happy with their current pay and thrilled with the idea that they're going to have a 401k plan and an ESOP at retirement, those people are more likely.
to be sticky and to stay with the company over a much longer period.
Anthony Codispoti (13:15)
So let me see if I understand sort of the construction of what's happening here behind the scenes. So on the one hand, this is a a great liquidity strategy for an owner. On the other, it's a wonderful retirement plan for the employees that is 80%-ish similar to a 401k, with some of the key differences being that the ESOP can borrow money, which it does in part to fund the exit of the owner.
banks giving a loan for that. The owner is also helling holding some kind of a seller note that's getting paid interest only for a period of time.
Kelly Finnell (13:52)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (13:53)
The Aesop is required to invest primarily in what?
Kelly Finnell (14:00)
The stock of the sponsoring company. So in our example, the restaurant company, the owner sells the stock that represents his ownership interest in that company to the ESOP. And so it's restaurant company stock that goes into the ESOP participants' accounts over a period of years.
Anthony Codispoti (14:24)
And then let's say I'm one of those employees that qualified, I participated, and in five years or twenty years I leave or I I retire. How am I getting paid out? Where is that money coming from?
How Employees Get Paid Out
Kelly Finnell (14:39)
The Internal Revenue Code requires that a company uh convert the closely held company stock, which is illiquid in the participant's account, into cash. And so the company buys back the stock that's in that departing depict participant's account so that participant receives cash like they would from any other retirement plan.
Anthony Codispoti (15:08)
And they receive it in a lump sum or it's paid out like a on an annuity basis?
Kelly Finnell (15:13)
It typically is paid out over time. And so there are three things that trigger a distribution from a retirement plan, from any retirement plan, whether it's an ESOP or a 401k. And those benefits are deaf, disability, retirement. And then the fourth benefit is termination of service or the fourth event, not a benefit, but the fourth event. And termination of service simply means that you quit or you got fired. So in terms of the timing of the payout.
If you leave for one of those first three reasons, deaf disability or retirement, then you start getting paid the next year. So you left in 26, you're going to start getting paid in 27, and you're going to receive 20% of the value of your account each year over a five-year period. So not an annuity that's going to pay you a benefit for life, but
you are gonna have a staged payout. If you leave for that fourth reason, you quitted, you got fired, then instead of starting getting paid out in 27, you'd get payments beginning in 2031, five years after the time that you left, and you'd still get paid out at the rate of twenty percent a year over a five year period. So those first three things have something in common.
Um, they are things that are beyond the control of the participant, deaf disability, or retirement. And so the participant gets paid out faster. That fourth thing is within the control of the participant, quitting or getting fired. And so the participant has to wait longer in that situation.
Anthony Codispoti (17:03)
What mechanisms are in place, Kelly, to ensure that the company has the cash to be able to pay folks?
Kelly Finnell (17:10)
It's a great question, and it's really critically important uh in structuring an ESOP. And so most companies use all of their cash during the first few years to pay off the ESOP debt. After that debt has been paid off, the company is gonna have free cash flow and it should use that free cash flow to start funding for that future.
liability. The e we call it the ESOP repurchase obligation. And so WISE companies set up a sinking fund and put a portion of their annual earnings that are not being used to pay debt anymore uh into that fund so that they can be sure they have the cash they need to pay off those benefits that are due to their employees.
Anthony Codispoti (18:10)
So if I'm a business owner that's looking to exit and I care about my employees and I want to make sure that the company remains intact, these folks continue to have jobs, an ESOP seems like a great option. If I'm an employer, I'm a business owner, I don't really care about my employees. I when I step out the door, I'm gone, what happens happens. That's not my business. Is there an advantage for me in that kind of mindset? Why might I consider an eSOP if I'm wired like that?
Kelly Finnell (18:36)
That's not a good candidate
for an ESOP. And so there are perhaps some advisors who in that situation would say, well, if you don't care about your employees, maybe you would care about the tax benefits that an e-sop uh offers. And they are very valuable. And maybe that should be your motivation for doing an ESOP. And so there might not be anything wrong with that approach, but we don't work with companies like that.
Anthony Codispoti (19:05)
Okay.
Kelly Finnell (19:05)
We've got an internal rule that if a business owner in a first conversation that we have with them, if they don't ask what's in this for my employees during that first call, then they might be a candidate for an ESOP, but they're not a candidate for us to work with. We want to work with business owners that are motivated to do this because they care about their employees.
the tax benefits are a great financial incentive for them to do this and help support business owners who want to take care of their employees, but we're really not interested in working with business owners where that is their primary motivation and taking care of their employees is kind of a nice afterthought.
Anthony Codispoti (19:58)
Why is that such a strict filter for you guys, Kelly? Why is it a requirement that your clients be so concerned about what's in it for their employees?
Kelly Finnell (20:09)
Well, because that aligns with our values. And so I think everybody uh who's been in business for a while and who has a successful business where they can filter those people that they want to work with, you know, has a set of values. And we only work with want to work with those clients where there is a value match.
Anthony Codispoti (20:36)
So you mentioned that there are tax benefits for the owner. Can you explain those for us?
The Owner Tax Benefit: Section 1042
Kelly Finnell (20:42)
Yeah, and the tax benefits are amazing and uh hard initially for an owner uh to believe are real. So the first tax benefit is for the owner who's selling his or her stock to the ESOB. There was a provision of the Internal Revenue Code that was added in nineteen eighty-four. It's section ten forty-two, and it is a like kind exchange provision.
And the most well-known and common like kind exchange provision in the code is section 1031, which deals with real estate. And so the concept in 1031 is I own a piece of commercial real estate. I sell that, I reinvest. And there are a long list of rules about when and how I reinvest, but I follow those rules and reinvest in other commercial real estate.
In that situation, I don't pay tax on the gain from that first piece of real estate I sold, but I get a transferred tax basis, which means that if I paid $2 million for that second piece of real estate, but I'd only paid a million for that first piece, then my tax basis in that second piece is one million dollars, even though I paid two million dollars for it. Same concept in section 1042.
I own stock in my company. I sell that stock. I get cash and seller notes. I reinvest in the stocks or bonds of a US domestic operating company. And again, lots of rules surrounding that. I completely
Anthony Codispoti (22:23)
A publicly
traded
Kelly Finnell (22:25)
It could be publicly traded and generally is, but doesn't have to be. And so we've had on a few occasion business owners whose children are starting a business. And the owner, the father, might use the proceeds from an eSOP sale to invest in their company. So it doesn't have to be a publicly traded company, but it almost always is because
These owners are looking to invest in securities that are gonna pay dividends and interest so that they have the cash flow that they need to fund their lifestyle in retirement.
Anthony Codispoti (23:07)
So I let's say I'm an owner and I'll pick just a small round number to make it easy. A million dollars is what I end up getting from the ESOP transaction. I'm able to take that million dollars and if I invest it in the stock market, uh I'm not paying any income tax on those funds. Is that correct?
Kelly Finnell (23:25)
Correct.
But again, I'm getting a transferred tax basis. And
Anthony Codispoti (23:30)
Explain that for us. Explain the transfer tax basis.
Kelly Finnell (23:33)
so let's assume that I had had a tax basis, which is the amount of after tax money I've invested in my company. That's the definition of tax basis. So I sold the company for one million dollars. Let's assume my tax basis was one hundred thousand dollars.
Now I've invested that million dollars in the stock market, but I don't get credit for that million dollars as my tax basis. I only get credit for the $100,000 because I got a transferred tax basis. The tax basis in my reinvestment is the same tax basis I had in the stock of my closely held company that I sold to the eSOP. And so if I ever
Uh sell oh those assets that are reinvested in, that's going to trigger a gain. So most of our clients are baby boomer business owners. So that's the group that was born between 46 and 64. So I'm right in the middle of that group. I'm 71. And so we've got people 10 years older than me, people 10 years younger than me, and they're going to reinvest with the goal.
Of having that reinvestment provide an income during retirement and hold on to that v investment until death. And at that point, uh that they get a stepped up basis in that stock. And when the estate sells that reinvestment asset, there's no gain.
Anthony Codispoti (25:16)
It has to be when the estate sells, or could it be that, hey, now I want to take some of those gains out of the market?
Kelly Finnell (25:22)
If you want to take some of those gains out of the market, you can do that, but you're going to pay tax. If you hold it till death and the estate sells it, then your tax deferral, which is the worst case scenario, tax deferrals are great, tax-free is better. And so uh and it's not an all-or-nothing proposition. So, in your example with a million dollars, maybe I sold a hundred thousand dollars worth. I had
a ten thousand dollar basis in that, so I pay some tax, but I still don't pay tax on the other nine hundred thousand.
Anthony Codispoti (26:01)
That's pretty awesome. So in what situations does an eSop not work? And I understand your filter, which is, hey, we only want to work with folks that are that care about the employees in the company that's being left behind. But generally speaking, when is an eSop not a good option for somebody who wants to exit their business?
The Company Tax Benefit: S-Corp ESOPs
Kelly Finnell (26:20)
Before we do that, can I talk about the other tax benefit?
Anthony Codispoti (26:24)
Just please. I didn't know there was more. Okay.
Kelly Finnell (26:26)
Because it's even more exciting.
You like the idea of being able to sell tax-free, you're gonna like this next tax benefit even more. So the first tax benefits for the owner, the second tax benefit is for the company. And so if I have a 100% ASOP-owned S corporation, and guess what? Almost every 100% ESOP, if it's not at the time they do the ESOP, then later it becomes
An S-corporation. So if I have that structure, then the company's income is never going to be subject to tax again. No tax at the company level because it's an S-corp. No tax at the shareholder level because the ASOP trustee is the shareholder, and the trustee of any retirement plan, whether it's a 401k plan.
Or an Aesop, those trustees under section 401 of the Internal Revenue Code are tax-exempt entities.
Anthony Codispoti (27:30)
That's interesting.
I hadn't considered because it's an S Corp, typically that would the that income would flow through to the shareholders. But you don't want the employees to have to pay income tax on that money because they're not actually getting it in their pockets, right?
Kelly Finnell (27:46)
That's right. And think about how much faster the company can now pay off this debt that it's taken on. Because it's not sending money to Uncle Sam or to its state government. It's retaining that money and using that cash flow to help pay off this debt that it's incurred.
Anthony Codispoti (28:09)
Phenomenal.
Kelly Finnell (28:10)
And so you can have a for profit business that operates on the same tax basis as a church or a synagogue. It operates tax free.
Anthony Codispoti (28:20)
That's wild to me.
Kelly Finnell (28:23)
And most business owners have no idea that's available.
Anthony Codispoti (28:28)
So I've known about ESOPs for years. I've done a little bit of research into them. This is the first time I've I've done the deep dive, and my my mind is just turning here. So so when is it not a good fit?
Kelly Finnell (28:40)
So uh there are certain financial metrics. So in order to be a good candidate for an ASOP, you the company needs to have at least two million dollars of adjusted EBITDA. It needs to have at least 35 employees, and it needs to have a strong successor management team. An ESOP is a form of internal transition and
Any internal transition, whether it's a management buyout or a leveraged recap or an ESOP, in order for that internal train uh transition strategy to work, you have to have somebody that's going to run the business as the current owner is slowing down and preparing for the exit. And so those are the three main things. And so companies that aren't good candidates are companies that are too small.
And I hate it, but at least a couple of times a week I talk to a business owner uh who is a great candidate for an eSOP in terms of the owner's goals of exiting and taking care of their employees. But they're just not big enough. You know, they've got nine employees and half a million dollars of eBITDA. And the law allows that company to establish an eSOP. But as a practical matter, the cost associated with implementing the eSOP.
are not going to be palatable to a company that's too small.
When an ESOP Isn’t a Good Fit
Anthony Codispoti (30:14)
Can you give us an idea of what that cost range could look like?
Kelly Finnell (30:17)
Yeah, it's gonna be over half a million dollars. Uh when people ask me what are the big disadvantages of an ESOP, I always tell them complexity. Esops are complex transactions. And of course, complexity means lots of lawyers. And so the company's gonna have a lawyer, the trustee's gonna have a lawyer, the bank that loans the money is going to have a lawyer.
And I've been a member of the Tennessee bar for 45 years now. and I have nothing against lawyers, but we all know legal fees are expensive. And so that's how you end up. Now, if you sell to private equity, your expenses are gonna be a lot more than that. So, in absolute dollars, an ESOP is expensive because of the complexity.
But it's not nearly as expensive as selling to private equity.
Anthony Codispoti (31:17)
'Cause there's still gonna be lawyers involved, you've still got a fee to pay to the and A brokers,
Kelly Finnell (31:22)
Exactly.
Anthony Codispoti (31:23)
and you're paying income tax on that money that you're getting.
Kelly Finnell (31:26)
Exactly
right. Yep.
Anthony Codispoti (31:29)
Interesting. So when you launched your firm, nineteen eighty-one, uh, it started out as Executive Financial Services. You know, today the tagline on your website is ESOPs are all we do. When
Kelly Finnell (31:44)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (31:44)
when you started the firm, was that the idea? Was is it ESOPs only from the beginning or no, there was a different vision?
Kelly Finnell (31:51)
No, the vision was retirement plan consulting, with ESOPs being a piece of that. And so that's the way we operated for over twenty years. Uh we did primarily four one K plans. We did some other types of plans, defined benefit pension plans, and uh another smattering of plans, and we would do one or two ESOPs a year. So it was a relatively small part of what we did.
I had a partner who helped me build that business. He was a CPA and a certified pension consultant. And we built a really nice business. And after 20 plus years, I said, Alan, I said, I am completely bored with the nonesop part of what we do. I said, Let's sell the company and go all in ESOPs. And he said, Well, I'm not sure that's right for me.
Why don't I buy the company from you? I'll take all of the non-esop part of what we've built, and that will give you the freedom to go all in ESOPs. I said, perfect. That's a deal. He's still operating that company successfully. And so, with that transition from being a full-service retirement plan consulting and administration firm to being an ESOP firm, that's when we transition from.
Executive Financial Services Inc. to EFS ESOP consultants. So I wanted to keep the executive financial services. So that's the EFS part of that, because that was a part of our history. But I wanted to make it clear that now all we do are ESOPs, so it's EFS ESOP consultants.
Anthony Codispoti (33:39)
So I understand the
being bored part, right? You're just bored of doing the same thing with the four one Ks over and over again. You wanted to kind of mix things up. But what made you confident that you could build a whole business around just eSops when it was such a small part of what you'd done up to that
Kelly Finnell (33:56)
You know, I am probably an unreasonably confident person. I I'll tell you the story, and it's a story that uh was one of those monumental, you know, life-changing events. I had decided that this is what I was gonna do, and it was time to have a discussion about this with my wife, who I've now been married to for forty-eight years.
And so we went on vacation to this beautiful tennis resort in South Carolina, had a great trip. And the last day of the trip, I said, uh, Beverly, I've made a decision, and this is where the business is headed in the future. And she just couldn't understand it, thought it was crazy. She said, you know, we've built this successful business, we've raised
two daughters, put them through private school, you know, have had great success. Uh, why are we taking this risk? And I said, well, it's either retire or do something different. I said, I just can't do uh this work that I don't enjoy and I'm not motivated uh to do. And she said, Okay, I trust you. Uh that's what we'll do.
And so that was all good. We were off to a great start, except for one little factor. We had that conversation in the summer of two thousand and eight.
Most people remember what happened on September fifteenth of two thousand and eight. That was the day that Lehman Brothers went bankrupt and the Great Recession began. And so my timing was the worst possible timing I could have had. Uh but and on top of that, we had a daughter that got married that year. And so we had
No income, new business, a daughter getting married. And so the timing was just terrible. But of course it worked out great.
Betting Big Before the Great Recession
Anthony Codispoti (36:15)
Tell us a little bit about the early days and how it started to work out. How were you getting your clients? When did you see things start to pick up? When were you sure that, okay, now we're on good ground?
Kelly Finnell (36:28)
it happened um immediately after the Great Recession was starting to recede. So in December of uh 2009, um I had been working with a company for a number of years. This was a big company. It was a defense contractor, it had twelve hundred employees, um, and they had uh forty nine percent uh ESOP.
And it was time for them to transition to a 100% ESOP owned structure. And so we got that deal, started working on that in uh December of 2009, got that transaction closed June 30th of 2010. And so went from, you know, being business being incredibly slow.
To doing the bus biggest transaction we ever did uh to come out of the Great Recession. And that case spurred lots of other cases for us in the defense contractor space. And so 2010 turned out to be a great year after a year and a half of not much to do. I'll add one other thing. I don't deal well with boredom and the I was
bored to death uh for about a year and a half during the Great Recession. And so that actually is when I wrote the book, The ESOP Coach.
Anthony Codispoti (38:06)
So I'm gonna come back to the book, but I wanna understand a little bit more about that first client and what came afterwards. How did you and that client find each other?
Kelly Finnell (38:15)
I had been referred to them by a financial advisor. there was a a big investment firm here in Memphis called Morgan Keegan. And the person that introduced me to this company was a financial advisor with Morgan Keegan that worked with this company. And so they made the introduction. And that was four or five years before we did this second stage ESOP transaction for them. I participated in their
uh annual board meeting in January and uh did an update on uh their Aesop and on uh what was going on with the law and legal changes that were happening in the ESOP world. And so they had been a client for four or five years when they decided, okay, Kelly, you're right. It's time for us to do the hundred percent deal and you're the man.
Anthony Codispoti (39:10)
And how did that end up leading to more work in that same defense con contractor space? Did they then refer you to some of their friends?
Kelly Finnell (39:18)
Yeah, and it was a well-known company. Um, and so uh it was kind of a bellwether transaction. To follow up on on the end of that story, I mentioned that when we started working with them, they had twelve hundred employees. Ten years later, they had grown to twenty two hundred employees, and so much of that I think was attributable to the fact that they had the eSop. And in February,
of twenty twenty so right before covet hit that company sold uh to a huge company in france for one point six five billion dollars and so those twenty two hundred employees split the profits from that sale
Anthony Codispoti (40:11)
Wow.
Kelly Finnell (40:11)
And
so that was one of the most successful ESOP transactions that has ever happened. And I was just very fortunate to be a part of that.
Anthony Codispoti (40:20)
And those twenty two hundred, obviously, it's sort of divvied up differently based on number of years they've been participating in the plan.
Kelly Finnell (40:29)
Yeah, it's based on the v uh number of shares that each participant had on their ASOP account, which you correctly stated is based on their longevity in the plan as well as their compensation.
Anthony Codispoti (40:47)
Incredible. Uh that changed a lot of lives, I bet. Okay, so let's talk about this boredom period, right? You start the company in the summer of 2008. Terrible timing because the Great Recession followed immediately after that. You don't have a lot to do for a year and a half before something finally clicks and the business really starts taking off. You don't do well being bored. A lot of entrepreneurs don't. And so tell us about the idea behind the book.
Writing The ESOP Coach
Kelly Finnell (41:17)
My father had always encouraged me to do it and I thought it was a crazy idea. You know, I didn't have time to do it. I had never undertaken anything like that. In fact, um I wrote an article for the law review uh when I was in law school and it was one of the most miserable uh experiences of my law school career. It was just drudgery. And so uh I had never done it. I'd had negative experiences.
uh writing technical treatises before, uh, but that was all outweighed by the fact that I didn't have anything else to do. And so I undertook it. And my mission in writing the book was for it not to be another technical treatise on ESOPs There are plenty of those out there. But there was nothing really in the ESOP literature
That talked about ESOPs from the business owner's perspective. So one of my jobs was to strip away all of the legalese and talk about ESOPs in business owner language with uh diagrams and cash flow schedules and all of those things that could illustrate an ESOP and its benefits in a way that a business owner
Could understand. And one of the keys to helping business owners understand was to have lots of case studies. Because I think business owners relate much better to case studies than anything else. And so I think there's six case studies in the book. And in the preface to the book, I said, you know, you probably want to read the first two or three chapters about what an ESOP is, how it works, and its tax benefits.
And then you might want to look at the case studies, find one that most closely looks like your business, read that one, and then the book is whatever, 211 pages or something. And so that's gonna get you halfway through the book. And then most entrepreneurs aren't gonna wanna touch the second half, which is all of the legalese, which you have to have. But I
Put it way in the back so that it didn't get in the way of understanding.
Anthony Codispoti (43:47)
So how helpful would you say this book has been in growing your business? Like how often do you think it leads to a client?
Kelly Finnell (43:51)
And it's been the best thing
I've ever done. Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (43:55)
Sa say more about once the book is written than how you leverage it.
Kelly Finnell (43:59)
Well, um there are lots of ways. Um I do lots of public speaking about ESOPs. So I've had four speaking engagements over the last six weeks, and I've been working on one that will happen in December. I'll be speaking to the Great Plains Federal Tax Institute in Omaha, which is a gathering of about four hundred lawyers and CPAs.
a lot of speaking events are, you know, Aesop industry speaking events, which is really kind of a pay-for-play situation. Um, but this is strictly an educational event. And so I've got an hour and a half in front of these lawyers and CPAs, and that's really how we've marketed the business through.
speaking engagements to professional advisors. um And those speaking engagements are so much easier to get when you've got a book.
I mean the the credibility that comes with having a book. I mean, I've I've talked to two financial advisors today already who have um referred us to great companies that are interested in ESOPs. And one of the things that they say when they're making that introduction is that and Kelly literally is the guy that wrote the book onesops.
Anthony Codispoti (45:34)
No.
Uh so my next question I've asked to some of my other guests who have written books, and I'd be curious to hear how your experience has been. Um, because in a lot of cases, like just the the notoriety of being the guy who literally wrote the book is enough. Um, and most folks find that nobody is actually not nobody, very few people are actually reading the book, but
Just having that credibility of being the guy who wrote the book is enough. Do you have any sense of how many folks that end up becoming clients have actually or that end up referring clients to you who've actually read the book or part of the book?
Kelly Finnell (46:14)
It was shocking to me because I thought that it was going to be the first situation that you described. I didn't think anybody was ever going to read this thing. My wife, who is an accountant, been married to her for 48 years, she hadn't read the book. It's I really didn't expect many people to read it. But it some of the stories I've gotten from clients are just amazing. Almost all of them now say, you know, I've read at least the first half of the book.
Um, I had one client located in Middle Tennessee, he's one of the best CFOs I've ever worked with. And when they decided to do an Aesop, he had a retreat with his senior management team and bought 20 copies of the book and did a one-day session for this senior management group walking through the book so that they would understand what an eSOP is and how it works.
There is a huge financial institution used to be based in New York. Now it's based in Nashville. And their Aesop specialist has told me multiple times that he uses the book in training that firm's employees, their financial advisors about what an ESOP is and how it works.
Anthony Codispoti (47:32)
It's become a textbook.
Kelly Finnell (47:35)
Become a great training aid and teaching aid.
Anthony Codispoti (47:40)
So, Kelly, I've I get a really nice feel from talking to you. You're you describe things in a way that's easy for kind of the lay person, a business owner to understand. You just got a nice delivery to you. I think that probably comes across really well to clients. But aside from sort of that personal connection that you're able to make, when folks make the decision to go with EFS, ESOP consultants today.
What are the things that they're getting from you that they wouldn't get from another firm that they might have been looking at?
Kelly Finnell (48:14)
think experience is probably foremost. I mean we've been through every business and political cycle over the last forty five years that you could ever expect. We've seen it all. I mean we did uh four ESOPs in the spring of two thousand and eight and help guide those people through the first two years of their Aesop life.
where their business was uh choked to death cash flow-wise by the Great Recession. We've been through COVID. We've been through dramatic changes uh in the Aesop practice. The Aesop law has changed some and almost all of those changes in the law have been very positive. But the way ESOPs are practiced has changed dramatically. We've been through and experienced all of that.
And so I think that experience is um invaluable in us working with clients. I think the other thing is the technical expertise. Um you have to know the law and be able to explain it where a business owner can understand it, but first you have to know it. And so the fact that you know I started out my eSop career.
writing the white paper for uh this firm in Massachusetts and then, you know, spent all of this time digging into all of the technical details, have worked on huge transactions and a lot of of medium and small transactions. Um, I was very fortunate. I had an incredible ESOP mentor.
this was the guy that wrote the BA tax portfolio on Nesops. And that doesn't mean anything to ninety-nine point nine percent of the people. But in the in the
Anthony Codispoti (50:14)
What does it mean though?
Kelly Finnell (50:15)
in the tax and business world, that means you are the acknowledged expert on this area. And so uh I was fortunate enough to have done a lot of work with that gentleman. He was a lawyer in Chicago, he died several years ago, but he was
the king of the Aesop community. And so I was just very fortunate to have had that experience, to have learned from the very best and have learned not just the technical side, but Jerry was the very best at explaining things in a way business owners could understand.
Anthony Codispoti (50:56)
Mm-hmm.
Kelly Finnell (50:56)
And so I come by part of that ability naturally, I guess, but I also saw the master
Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (51:09)
How did the two
of you get hooked up, you and the mentor?
Kelly Finnell (51:12)
You know, it was a crazy story. I had a friend in uh Portland, Oregon, who was with a big financial institution, and he thought that he might want to get uh their advisors involved in the eSop world. And he knew I was involved in eSops. So he called me and he said, Kelly, this lawyer's in Chicago. He said, I'm gonna go meet with them. I'm gonna bring some of my people. Would you wanna meet with
Us and I knew the guy. I mean, I knew his name. I'd had never met him, the lawyer before. And so we met in Chicago and spent all day together one day in this meeting. My buddy in Portland decided not to pursue uh the eSop world for his advisors, but it gave me the experience of forming a relationship with Jerry.
Anthony Codispoti (52:05)
That's really cool. You know, I've t I talk with a lot of exit planners and MA folks on this show. And the one thing I hear over and over again, and I've seen it in my own personal experiences too, is that as a business heads towards a traditional exit, a lot of deals fall apart before they reach the finish line. Uh you'll hear folks say a a deal dies a thousand deaths if it's ever gonna close at all. Do similar risks exist for closing out an eShop transaction?
Deal Risks & Plan Administration
Kelly Finnell (52:34)
Yeah, we call that the execution risk. The risk that between the business owner the time the business owner makes a decision and the time the deal closes, the execution risk is that it falls apart. And you're right, in a traditional sale to a third party, that happens very frequently. It almost never happens in an ESOP situation. And so one of the advantages for a selling shareholder of an ESOP is they have
a much higher level of certainty that the transaction's going to close.
Anthony Codispoti (53:11)
So let's say that the transaction does close and then there's the ongoing administration of the plan. If a plan is going to get tripped up during that ongoing administration, what are some of the ways that that would traditionally have?
Kelly Finnell (53:26)
I think maybe the first way is uh by not hiring a professional TPA. So TPA stands for third-party administrators. And there aren't that many that specialize in TPA work for ESOPs. It's completely different than doing uh TPA work for a 401k plan. So you really need one of those firms that specializes in doing that work.
And if you don't engage them, then there are lots of opportunities for things to go sideways. I think another risk is uh the uh founder of the company who sold to the eSOP uh exits and something happens with the management team, and for whatever reason they don't stick together. And so now you've got
a rudderless ship. You've got a ship without the founder and without that management team that he had put in place. Now that risk is really mitigated in the ESOP situation because nothing's changed about the company's culture and those people are have a tremendous financial incentive to stay with the company because of the benefits that the ESOP is going to provide. But that would be a risk.
Another risk would be for a business to ignore the uh ESOP repurchase obligation, which we talked about a little while ago. If you don't set aside the money uh to make good on that obligation, then perhaps your only alternative is going to be to sell the ESOP company. because that that's the ultimate safety valve.
for those companies that have not planned properly for it is if you sell the company, uh that satisfies the repurchase obligation because participants are paid off through the sales proceeds.
Anthony Codispoti (55:35)
How often have you seen that happen?
Kelly Finnell (55:38)
More than we used to. Um, and so we've had maybe one client a year on average that is a one hundred percent Aesop owned company that's decides to sell uh to a third party. Um and so for decades that almost never happened, but over the last five years, that's happening more and more.
Anthony Codispoti (56:04)
What do you think's driving it?
Kelly Finnell (56:06)
I think that a lot of these eSop companies are performing extremely well and they're getting great offers from private equity and from strategic buyers.
Anthony Codispoti (56:18)
How often do you find that a company is in a in a bad spot because they didn't site set aside enough cash for that repurchase obligation?
Kelly Finnell (56:26)
It's
it's very rare among our clients, because you know, we're gonna coach 'em to make sure that they do that. Uh, but I know it does happen. Um we've got a company uh that I've known of for a long time. They have one of the oldest ESOPs in the country. Their ESOP was established in nineteen seventy-four, uh, after Labor Day of that year.
And Labor Day is the day that Orissa was enacted, which is totally appropriate and not coincidental. And this company has been able to pay off participants over these many years, but now they've got three of their key people, the three people that are running this business are all about the same age.
And are all planning to exit at about the same time. And between the three of them, they hold 60 or 70 percent of the plan's assets. And so um, you know, they're not clients, but I've known them and went to lunch with uh the CEO of the company and said to them, Look, your only option is to sell. You guys are behind the eight ball. And I said, That
is your only option at this point because you you hadn't planned the way that you should have.
Anthony Codispoti (57:55)
And that's something that you ensure that your clients are doing. Yeah.
Kelly Finnell (57:58)
Yep.
To the best of our ability.
Anthony Codispoti (58:02)
So you already explained the benefits that you got from a wonderful mentor who, you know, helped to bring you up and and show you kind of the ropes. That's a great way for folks to learn. Um, another way that we end up learning really powerful lessons are through hard experiences that we go through. Kelly, what is one of the hardest things that you've ever had to go through and what did that experience teach you?
Kelly Finnell (58:30)
I think it was the thing that we talked about earlier. Going on vacation on a tennis trip with my wife and breaking the news to her that this business, the full service retirement plan design, consulting and administration business that had been so successful and good to us was going to go away. And then to have that decision being made with
Absolutely no foresight as to what was coming with the Great Recession. That was a very difficult period of time.
Anthony Codispoti (59:07)
So you talked about writing the book during that time because you don't
Kelly Finnell (59:10)
With the
Anthony Codispoti (59:11)
do well being bored. So that's good. It gives you something to do, but there's still the uncertainty of not knowing is business gonna pick up? Is this gonna turn around? Did I make a horrible decision? Like what were you doing to deal with those negative voices? How were you getting through this year and a half period of uncertainty?
Kelly Finnell (59:34)
Us staying busy with the book. Yeah. That uh
Anthony Codispoti (59:39)
And even though
it wasn't bringing in income that was enough to kind of keep you sane.
Kelly Finnell (59:43)
Yeah, fortunately, you know, I had sold out to the person that I had been in partnership with. And so I was getting his business wasn't affected by the Great Recession. Um, and so he was making payments for the the business that I had sold to him. You know, I had accumulated uh some assets during the the first half of my business career.
So uh we survived getting through that, getting through our first daughter's wedding, and then had the experience of the great turnaround d completing the ASOP for that big defense contractor client.
Anthony Codispoti (1:00:30)
Kelly, are you using AI at all in your work?
Kelly Finnell (1:00:34)
Every day. Um we received an RFI uh from a financial advisor uh yesterday, I guess. And um we had a template RFI response um uh agent that we had created and so we used we took the RFI that we received, put it into chat.
had chat populate it with our answers. Then there were some questions that that weren't in our deck that uh we had to add manually and then had chat you know dress it up and we'll be able to send that out tomorrow.
AI in the ESOP Business
Anthony Codispoti (1:01:21)
It's incredible, isn't it?
Kelly Finnell (1:01:23)
It is amazing.
Anthony Codispoti (1:01:25)
So it's not there yet, but can you imagine a time in the future where AI might threaten what you do, replace what it is that you do?
Kelly Finnell (1:01:36)
No, but I think it's going to uh make what we do um much more streamlined. I think we're I think it's gonna increase our capacity to do business because we're gonna be able to do things so much quicker. So we have many of our processes already now built into uh our practice using AI. but the biggie.
the most time-consuming thing that we do in our business is the Aesop feasibility study. We're working with a great company now that is a consulting business, extremely profitable, big business for a business of its type. It's got about 130 employees, a CEO who not only is a brilliant person, but a very kind, humble, great person to work with.
And as soon as we get finished implementing their eSop at the end of this year, uh we're gonna become a client of theirs and they're going to uh consult with us on how we can automate our e-sop feasibility process using AI.
Anthony Codispoti (1:02:53)
Well, I see your face lighting up as you talk about that.
Kelly Finnell (1:02:54)
Yeah, and so that will talk about
that will increase our capacity at least fifty percent, perhaps more.
Anthony Codispoti (1:03:02)
Wow. But you don't see a time in the future where I could s sit down at AI and say, put together an ESOP plan for me.
Kelly Finnell (1:03:11)
I don't think so. Um this uh client had created an eSOP feasibility study on his own um using AI. And he said, Let me send this to you guys. And so we said, Okay, look, we're not gonna charge you to create the feasibility analysis because about eighty percent of what AI did for you with your excellent prompting.
was great, but I don't think AI's ever gonna get the other twenty percent. And this was a guy whose business is built on their AI expertise. So for the average business owner, it might be twenty percent or forty percent of them doing it themselves that turns out to be correct and usable.
Anthony Codispoti (1:04:09)
Hmm. So Kelly, as you think about the work that you're doing today, what is it that you most want to be remembered for?
Kelly Finnell (1:04:17)
Think helping business owners and their families while helping them take care of their employees. That's what gives me the greatest satisfaction. If a business owner sells to private equity, then they've helped themselves and their family. And that's great. I mean, I applaud professionals who help business owners achieve that goal.
But to me it is much more satisfying to have achieved those two goals while at the same time taking care of their one hundred and thirty employees and their families.
Anthony Codispoti (1:05:00)
Is there a rule in business that you would never break no matter what?
Kelly Finnell (1:05:05)
integrity. Um and so uh we want to work with companies that value integrity and um we're always going to shoot it straight with our clients and maybe to an extreme uh I tend not to have a filter and I tell people the way it is with
not much diplomacy. I want to be straightforward so everybody understands. Uh and so I think those are, you know, really important principles for our business.
Anthony Codispoti (1:05:47)
Kelly, I just have one more question for you today. And before I ask it, I'm going to do three quick things for the audience. First of all, anybody that wants to get in touch with Kelly, two things. You can go to their website, bunch of great information there, execfin.com. So ex e-c f I N dot com. Or I'll give you his email address. You can just go right to the horse here, like kfin at execfin.com.
One more time, it'll be in the show notes, but kfin at execfin.com. Also, if you're enjoying the show, please take a moment to subscribe wherever you're listening. It also sends a signal that helps others discover our podcast. So thank you for taking a quick moment to spread the word. And if you advise business owners planning their exit or succession, here's a lever most of your clients don't know they have.
A program that counterintuitively turns their healthcare plan into higher net profits, freeing up cash to fund
Kelly Finnell (1:06:45)
I mean.
Anthony Codispoti (1:06:45)
the transition and raising the value of the business itself. It's backed by Bain Capital Insurance, so you can recommend it with confidence. Bring your clients that kind of win and they'll pass your name along, addbackbenefits.com. So, last question for you, Kelly. A year from now, what is one very specific thing that you hope to be celebrating?
Kelly Finnell (1:07:08)
Um, the completion of automating our feasibility analysis through AI. I mean, that will be that's been a goal of mine for two or three years. And it's very difficult to do that internally. Uh, and I was just very fortunate to have found this client that we're gonna do an eSOP for and uh, you know, enjoy the process of working with him and the revenue that that generates. But
As importantly, finding the the group that is going to help us achieve this goal that I've had for three years.
Anthony Codispoti (1:07:47)
Outstanding. Kelly Finnell from EFS ESOP Consultants, I want to be the first to thank you for sharing both your time and your story with us today. I really appreciate you being here.
Kelly Finnell (1:07:57)
Thank you very much, Anthony.
Anthony Codispoti (1:07:59)
Hey folks, that's a wrap on another episode of the Inspired Stories Podcast. Thanks for learning with us. And if one thing stood out, put that into action today.
Connect with Kelly Finnell:
Website: execfin.com
Email: kfin@execfin.com




