🎙️ An Owner Nearly Sold for $6 Million. Bob Scarlata Got Him $28 Million All Cash
Bob Scarlata paid for college and law school by renting mini fridges to UConn students. In 1986 he bought a business brokerage office with almost no assets and rebuilt it into an M&A firm. Today he is Senior Managing Director of WhiteHorse Partners, a Nashville area firm that helps owners of privately held, middle market companies sell or buy businesses.
Bob explains why he takes companies to market without an asking price, how one owner who nearly sold for $6 million closed at $28 million all cash, and why every seller he represents gets a quality of earnings report. He also shares why he pays for each seller's executive physical, when an ESOP beats an outside buyer, and how gratitude, meditation and exercise got him through near bankruptcy.
✨ Key Insights You'll Learn:
How upfront deposits paid for the first 180 mini fridges
Why no middle market company is bulletproof, even one as famous as Eastman Kodak
Why the purchase price matters less than a business you can grow
How a Gulf War slowdown pushed Bob from small businesses into the middle market
Why owners shouldn't tell their advisor what they think the business is worth
How going to market without a price drew 30 offers and $28 million all cash
What a quality of earnings report is, and why WhiteHorse pays half the seller's cost
Why deals tend to fall apart three times between the letter of intent and closing
How an ESOP sale can defer taxes, and when a higher outside offer wins
Why hiring the best people in their niche, at their price, pays for itself
🌟 Bob's Key Influences:
His father: loaned him $3,000 to start the fridge business
Linda Lerner: a high-priced SEC attorney who showed him the value of paying for the best
A Harvard resilience researcher: four daily steps, starting with a list of gratitudes
👉 Hear why one owner nearly left $22 million on the table, and what changed his outcome.
Listen to the full episode here
Transcript
Renting Mini Fridges at UConn
Anthony Codispoti (00:00)
Welcome to another edition of the Inspired Stories Podcast, where leaders share their experiences so we can learn from their successes and be inspired by how they've overcome adversity. As you listen today, let one idea shape what you do next. My name is Anthony Codispoti, and today's guest paid for his undergraduate degree and his law degree by renting mini fridges to college students.
He and his brothers started with 180 refrigerators at the University of Connecticut and grew to more than 500. After law school, he spent 10 years in sales engineering, finishing as North American sales manager for camp machinery, where he sold industrial converting and coding equipment to companies like Eastman Kodak. In 1986, he bought a business brokerage office with almost no assets, untrained staff, and no business plan.
He rebuilt it into a highly respected mergers and acquisitions firm. Bob Scarlata is the senior managing director of Whitehorse Partners, a Nashville area MA advisory firm that helps owners of privately held companies across the US and Canada sell or buy businesses. He has taken part in the sale of hundreds of middle market companies. He is also the author of Manage to Sell Your Business: Wealth Creation: Secret of the Pros.
But before we get into all that good stuff, today's episode is brought to you by my company, AddBack Benefits Agency. And if you advise business owners heading towards an exit, this is a lever most of your clients don't know they have. See, here's the problem. Your business owner clients are overspending on health insurance every year. That's money leaking out of the business, and a prospective buyer will see it in the numbers. But now there's a program from Bain Capital Insurance you can put in front of them to change that.
It doesn't replace their group health plan. It fills in the first dollar gaps and it can even cover part-timers. Employees get unlimited access to doctors, therapists, and prescriptions with no co-pays or deductibles to meet. And here's why it matters for your practice. This program actually increases your client's net profits. See, we recently helped a client add, that's add $900 per employee per year to their bottom line.
Results vary, but gains like that increase the value of a business and raise the price buyer will pay. Your client gets stronger and more valuable, you become the advisor who found the money and the one they tell their friends about. Learn more at AddBackBenefits.com. All right, back to our guest today, the senior managing director and founder of White Horse Partners, Bob Scarlata. Thanks for making the time to share your story today.
Bob Scarlata (02:43)
It's great to be here with you, Anthony.
Anthony Codispoti (02:46)
So, Bob, you had the entrepreneurial zeal very early on. You and your brothers started renting these small two cubic foot refrigerators to students at UConn. And in that first year, you had 180 of them out in dorm rooms. You later grew it to 500 fridges out at any given time. This helped to pay for your undergrad and your law school. Tell me how you came up with the idea, how you funded those first fridges, how you marketed this, how you fulfilled the orders. I want to hear how this thing birthed and how it worked.
Bob Scarlata (03:17)
It's a long story, but I'll keep it short. Um, a very good friend of mine at the university was uh on the school um advisory committee and they had suggested that the advi the school allow two cubic foot refrigerators in dorm rooms. Up to that point they had been prevented. He graduated and for some reason I just said, Well, I think that's an opportunity for me and so I uh raised a couple thousand dollars. uh
Bought the few refrigerators, asked for a significant deposit on the on the cost of the refrigerator, got 100% of it up front, basically paid for the cost of the refrigerator with the deposit and the initial payment. And uh and set out to to uh find find customers. And it w it turned out to be fairly easy. Uh we used an advertising agency out of New York City to help us.
make sailcloths that were the side of a truck. And so we would walk in w right right into a triangle and there the truck would be with this big advertisement on it. And we put a little business card under everybody's dorm room door and that's how we got customers. But the most fun thing we did was a few years later, most of our clients were uh women. Most of our customers were women. And so we decided to buy roses from Brazil.
at twenty five cents each. And so for every woman we put a rose in their refrigerator and uh it just created more excitement about it. The delivery men loved it. Every single delivery man came back with a date at the end of every night.
Anthony Codispoti (05:04)
I
love this. Okay, so where did you raise the money from? Couple thousand dollars is this family?
Bob Scarlata (05:10)
Yeah, I think my father loaned me three thousand dollars. And and I remember at a breakfast table with my mother during the summer, dad asked her, Do you what do you think of this? And she said, Fine, as long as my son doesn't become a full time refrigerator man.
Anthony Codispoti (05:28)
So do you remember the economics? Like what is it that you paid for the refrigerators? How much the deposit
Bob Scarlata (05:33)
About forty two about forty two dollars.
Anthony Codispoti (05:35)
forty two dollars. And then people had to put a forty two dollar deposit down to
Bob Scarlata (05:40)
So
it's forty five.
Anthony Codispoti (05:46)
And so these were
refrigerators you could continue to rent out again the next year or are they so banged up that they kind of have a one year loan?
Bob Scarlata (05:53)
We interestingly
enough, we did the most damage to the refrigerators, not the students. Think about it, a refrigerator stands in a corner and just sits there. And uh no, we uh they lasted for oh my god. We saw we sold the company twelve or thir we we liquidated the company twelve or thirteen years later and we still had the original refrigerators. Yeah. Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (06:16)
Wow. Okay.
Uh and this was back in the eighties, seventies and eighties.
Bob Scarlata (06:22)
Correct. Well it was actually
it was actually nineteen seventy two.
Anthony Codispoti (06:26)
Okay, so nobody had credit cards. How were you making like did you get paid up front on these then from the college students? Okay. Go ahead.
Bob Scarlata (06:31)
Yes, we got paid ch checks and cash.
Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (06:37)
Okay. Uh and but you continued to run this business after you graduated. You said you liquidated it like twelve or thirteen years later. So this was something you were still doing on the side? Okay.
Bob Scarlata (06:44)
Well my my brother was doing it. I
had two brothers and they they both succeeded me and they continued it.
Anthony Codispoti (06:52)
At it.
Bob Scarlata (06:53)
Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (06:53)
Okay, so you finished law school, you went to University of Miami in nineteen seventy-six,
Bob Scarlata (06:57)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (06:58)
you spent the next ten years in sales engineering, and by nineteen eighty-two you were running North American sales for which company?
Bob Scarlata (07:06)
A company called Comf Machinery Corporation.
Anthony Codispoti (07:09)
comp machinery, okay. And they build they were converting and build converting and and coating equipment for manufacturers. Yeah.
Bob Scarlata (07:17)
That's correct. They they made
it the the world's best equipment that was uh all custom made for companies like Three Corporation, Mobile Chemical, Eastman Kodak, DuPont, um remarkable machines that took twelve to eighteen months to to to finish, to complete.
Anthony Codispoti (07:36)
Wow. And nineteen eighty six you personally sold five million dollars worth of equipment. Three million of that came from a single customer. How'd you land that?
Bob Scarlata (07:47)
Well, I I can't take sole responsibility for it. The the equipment was just fabulous and these companies had to have the very best equipment. And um so it was just persistence. That was with Eastman Kodak. Eastman Kodak was building up their business in China and they needed to order these machines and so they ordered them from us.
Anthony Codispoti (08:09)
Okay.
Bob Scarlata (08:10)
And this was when Eastman Kodak was still in business before the digital camera was invented and
You one one of my prime examples as to why none of us are bulletproof, um, middle market companies especially. I mean look at Eastman Kodak. They had they had like number one, number two brand recognition in the world. They invented the digital camera and yet they went out of business. To think that a middle market company is bulletproof i is is is total and completely false.
my thesis is at a certain point in time when there's enough, maybe take some chips off the table.
Anthony Codispoti (08:52)
So this is part of what you coach your clients on today.
Bob Scarlata (08:56)
Yes, it's what and I think i it's my next book or next pamphlet is going to be about the risk associated with owning a middle market company, which is not inconsiderable. It's s it's very significant owning a a middle market company.
Buying a Business Brokerage in 1986
Anthony Codispoti (09:16)
So I wanna get to this point where we talk a little bit more about present day, but let's talk about the the genesis because in 1986, so you'd been working for conf machinery for a handful of years now.
Bob Scarlata (09:30)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (09:31)
you decide to buy a business brokerage office.
Bob Scarlata (09:34)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (09:35)
No assets. This company had no assets, they had outdated equipment, and I don't even know what that looks like in 1986 for the equipment to be outdated. Okay. Uh
Bob Scarlata (09:42)
Well, no computers. Yeah. Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (09:45)
No really pipeline of prospects. What why were you attracted to this business? What was bringing you into it?
Bob Scarlata (09:53)
Um my m I had a few relatives that were in a rel related brokerage business, not necessarily the MA business, and they had done well. And y you know, uh I I've had friends who say, you know, once you work for yourself, you're unemployable. Well, I was employed for ten years, but I felt like I was always unemployable, that I should have been out on my own. uh
And so my neighbor worked for this business brokerage business and it sounded very interesting to me. And so this this was a a natural end for it. So I said to him, as you know, St. Teresa says you better know what you want because you might just get it. I said to him, I'd love to own your uh I'd love to be in your business if I could own it. And the the owner of the company that time was doing poorly and needed to get out. And so th I consummated the transaction.
Anthony Codispoti (10:54)
You must have gotten a good deal on it.
Bob Scarlata (10:57)
I wouldn't say necessarily I got a good deal on it, but
Anthony Codispoti (10:59)
Okay.
Bob Scarlata (11:00)
uh it it this is a personal bias. Folks focus so much on the purchase price up front. Um that's not where the juice is. So you overpay a little bit. So what? If it's a good business and and you feel motivated and can grow it, you're never even gonna rem remember overpaying for it. Who cares?
Anthony Codispoti (11:18)
So what were the good parts of the business? I kind of rattled off a few of the uh the warts there, if you will.
Bob Scarlata (11:24)
It
i well, i if this is both good and bad, it was a franchise. And so they provided three weeks of training. They they had the right forms, they had formats, they had uh managers in the field to help you. And I felt that all that would be helpful relative to building the business.
Anthony Codispoti (11:45)
Was it was it helpful that franchise training?
Bob Scarlata (11:49)
I would say initially it was helpful, yes. I grew f grew very tired of having the franchise look over my shoulder and uh I think in nineteen eighty nine we left the franchise and that was a good decision.
Early Growth Plan and the 1992 Gulf War Pivot to Middle Market
Anthony Codispoti (12:02)
Okay. So when you first bought it, what was your plan? How were you gonna grow it?
Bob Scarlata (12:06)
uh That's a good qu question, Anthony. I laugh because I wouldn't say that I had a uh good plan. The plan was basically uh to knock on a lot of doors and uh find business owners that were were willing to get out. The the essence of the business is your inventory, having good businesses to sell. Okay. If you have good businesses to sell, you're gonna do a good business, right?
So that's that's the essence of it. Um I don't know if it's appropriate to fast forward, but if I can fast forward to nineteen ninety-two, uh the the Gulf War kicked our butt. Uh it basically uh two of my best guys left. Um the Republican Guard was gonna going to defeat us in the Middle East. No one was buying small businesses, which were basically buy yourself a job, right? No one was doing that. And so
From uh August or so until February, there was no business at all. And I found a partner who knew about middle market companies, and so we moved up market to companies that would sell for a million dollars or more. And I took special training with the uh an organization, a business brokerage uh organization called the MA Source. And basically that was the genesis of our current business.
specializing in middle market companies, which are wonderful.
Anthony Codispoti (13:37)
So this
is interesting because I hear this story over and over again how one door closes in an aspect of the business. Everything dries up because of the war that's going on, right? And you're like, what are we gonna do? And if you look back now, I'm gonna guess there's a sense of gratitude for going through that dark tunnel because now it sh it forced you to shift gears into something else. You were selling these really small businesses, now you went middle market.
And it sets you up for the rest of your future. Am I kind of connecting the dots in the right way there, Bob?
Bob Scarlata (14:11)
Well yes, and and frankly, that wasn't the first uh black event in in my forty year career. And I'd like to say for the most part, every one of those negative events uh pr produced a positive outcome.
Anthony Codispoti (14:31)
Can you give us another example?
Bob Scarlata (14:31)
So I'm a hundred percent
I'm a hundred percent on board with what you're saying. Uh
Anthony Codispoti (14:35)
Yeah.
Bob Scarlata (14:36)
a negative event is an opportunity.
Anthony Codispoti (14:39)
Can can you share another example, Bob? Because I I think these are really great for folks to hear because so many times business owners, they find themselves in this space where they're like, this isn't working. I need to throw in the towel. I just need to quit. And sometimes it's not the quitting that needs to happen. It's just an adjustment. It's a pivot. It's a turn.
Bob Scarlata (15:00)
Yeah, I I I mentioned that I uh got got into the middle market MA business in nineteen ninety two with a partner. We had a falling out in oh thirteen and I decided to go out on my own. uh again, but without a partner. And we had a few deals that we took with us. We were successful in selling them. We're a virtual company.
we have we I like to say that we cover ten time zones from Scotland to Southern California. And it's been a it's been a wonderful, wonderful experience. Uh we covered the entire United States, done deals in Canada, um and it's so all those all those negative things uh you look back at them to make your point and f they they opened a new door, a new opportunity.
And all you had to do was kind of sit quietly, not get excited, and continue to do what you do best. And that's in each and every instance, I did that.
Anthony Codispoti (16:07)
Can you say more about the splitting of the partnership there in 2013? How did that ultimately lead to something better for you? What what did you change in in the wake of that?
Bob Scarlata (16:19)
Well, the former company uh my my my partner had huge ambitions and at one time we were up to two hundred and fifty people and it was a total and complete monster. You had to feed the monster at all times. And so when when we split, I vowed that we were gonna keep it lean and mean. And in and as a matter of fact, when I hired our COO, I gave him uh the world's shortest job description.
You're going to do everything that I don't want to do. And he's he's been with me now for 10 years, and and it it's worked out. He's in North Carolina. I'm in Nashville. We have a great relationship. Uh, we keep it fun. We we laugh a lot. you know, he said to me at one time he was in uh in it working for us from Europe, and he he said that uh
His daughters would say to him I that they heard him laughing upstairs in his office and they would call it cackling with Bob. uh
Anthony Codispoti (17:28)
Sounds like a AM radio show.
Bob Scarlata (17:31)
Abs a hundred percent. A hundred percent. Exactly. It's it's important to keep it fun, it's important to keep it lively, it's important to keep a sense of ourselves, I think, especially in working with clients.
Anthony Codispoti (17:47)
Say a bit more about the the previous iteration of the business where it turned into this two hundred and fifty person monster and there was this sense of always having to feed the monster.
Bob Scarlata (17:59)
Well it was an it was an offshoot, if you will, of uh a kind of Geneva Corporation. Geneva was really the the developer of the modern middle market MA business. They did an incredible job. They they uh put workshops on all across the the United States for six hours with lunch at a f at a Marriott or something. They talked to business owners about how they might cash in their chips, how they might sell their company.
And so we followed that model. But that model was very expensive. And and so that was the that was the engine that that had to be fed no matter what. And eventually what happened? You you you have disgruntled you have disgruntled customers and the internet evolved and you get bad reviews and that's the beginning of the end.
Anthony Codispoti (18:53)
The disgruntled customers were just coming from perhaps agents who were not well trained, they weren't putting time in.
Bob Scarlata (18:59)
Well, they
they they received a va they spent a lot of money on evaluation and got a price that was less than they needed and so they were very unhappy about it. And we No, and and
Anthony Codispoti (19:10)
Okay. They didn't like they didn't like reality. That's what it was.
The Free Valuation Approach
Bob Scarlata (19:14)
and frankly Anthony, we've taken a totally and completely opposite uh approach to the marketplace. We we want business owners to know their value and as a result we offer the valuation at no cost.
Anthony Codispoti (19:29)
Really?
Bob Scarlata (19:29)
No commitment,
no obligation. And the the the genesis of this was a buy-side representation that we had uh working for a private equity group that had bought a company we were representing on the sell side. And they liked what we did so much that they hired us to go find more companies in the same industry. And I s we had a we have we had a great front end marketing uh department, if you will.
And I said, Well, we need a hook. We need something to get these business owners who were taking our calls to say, I'm interested. And I said, Well, the hook is no cost, no no obligation, no commitment, valuation. We'll come and present it to them. And then we we would surprise them, Anthony. We would present them with the valuation, okay? At the same time, we would present them with an executed letter of intent. Exactly at that.
valuation. Okay? Which they never ever expected. And our first deal right out of the chute was a forty eight million dollar deal in Russellville, Arkansas.
Anthony Codispoti (20:41)
So wait, at the same time that you're doing the valuation, you're going out shopping for a potential buyer?
Bob Scarlata (20:46)
Well we had a buyer. This was a buy side engagement on our part.
Anthony Codispoti (20:49)
so this is a one time thing. This wasn't what you did for everybody that you were offering a free b free valuation to.
Bob Scarlata (20:55)
No, because that's on the sell side. So uh we we had this engagement with this
Anthony Codispoti (21:00)
Cara.
Bob Scarlata (21:01)
private equity group to go out find them more companies to acquire. And this is how we did it.
Anthony Codispoti (21:04)
Yeah. Oh, beautiful. I love that. I
love surprising the customer in a good way.
Bob Scarlata (21:13)
Oh, it's just you know, I'll never forget we were presenting to two brothers in Seattle, uh, Washington. And we put we put them put the the valuation and then the letter of intent in front of them. And you know, as you as you're as you're an old warrior, you learn that you have to sit and be quiet. Okay? So the valuations in front of them, I'm looking at them, they're not.
doing or saying anything at all, okay? And then one of the brothers says, Wow. And we went on to close the transaction.
There there's kind of a misconception, I think. Common wisdom is that most business owners think their business is worth more than it than uh than it really is.
Anthony Codispoti (22:06)
That's what I hear all the time.
Bob Scarlata (22:08)
And and we don't see that. I see the opposite. And I'll I'll tell you some stories about it if you want to hear that.
Anthony Codispoti (22:16)
I would. And do you think it's because you're playing now in the middle market as opposed to the lower market? So you're working with folks that maybe are a bit more sophisticated?
Bob Scarlata (22:26)
Well, let me let me repeat what I said. What I said is I we don't find that most of our clientele has unreasonable expectations about the value of their company. In fact, when we approach them to do evaluation, we do not want to know what they think it's worth. And they should not want us to know what they think it's worth. Okay? They don't know. They don't have a clue. Seriously. So um uh the a transaction we just closed a couple of months ago.
The owner was in the graphic arts business. The owner had it sold twice to employees for six million dollars each. Quite fortunately, in neither case could they come up with the money. Based on his financials, we valued his company at ten million. He waits he waits a year and a half. He doesn't he doesn't take us up on it immediately, which was just absurd. He he he's a wonderful guy and and he created an incredible business. uh
But a little a little different in some ways. Anyway, he hires us a year and a half later. We go to market. He's he's now doing, I'm gonna say, 70, 80% better than he was at the time we valued it at 10 million, okay? We go to market, 90 books we send out, 30 offers ranging in size, between 15 million and 28 million all cash. We did the 28 million all cash.
It was even better than I'm making it sound like. And we closed the deal. So without even knowing it, Anthony, he would have left twenty two million dollars on the table.
Why a Buyer Paid $28M Instead of $10M
Anthony Codispoti (24:08)
So I want to understand a little bit more about this particular deal. Um, so I understand the gap. I can understand, I can wrap my head around the gap between the six million and the ten million valuation. But I wanna know what happens between that ten million dollar valuation that you gave and why there was an ultimate buyer that was willing to pay so much more for it. What were they seeing?
Bob Scarlata (24:30)
Um that's a very, very good question, a very astute question. The um several things happened. The the the buyer was a private equity group, they own three or four similar companies, and and I hope they aren't listening to your podcast, frankly. In any case. All right, so um and and they were gonna be marketing their division.
And I'm sure their division was going to sell at a very high multiple. And so they were buying this client company that was going to fit perfectly with respect to their other companies at a lower multiple than they intended to sell it for. It was pure arbitrage. And they were going to do it very quickly. And they actually ended up doing it within forty five days after they closed our clients' deal. So that's plus
Right now is a really great time to sell companies. Um multiples are high, there's a lot of money available to looking for a home. Uh it's it's it's as active as I've ever seen it in forty years. So that doesn't
Anthony Codispoti (25:39)
What do you
Bob Scarlata (25:40)
totally answer your question. Uh but one increase.
Anthony Codispoti (25:43)
Well, no, I get it. Yeah, I get what
you're saying, because they were gonna turn and flip it and it had a multiplicative effect on their deal because they were able to package it together with some other things.
Going to Market Without a Price
Bob Scarlata (25:55)
Right. The the essence of this is it's critical to go to market without a price. Okay? And to do both a buck buckshot approach to marketing and a rifle approach to marketing. So rifle approach would be synergistic buyers. Buckshot would be just uh like on Axial. Axial is a uh an MA internet site and you get all kinds of buyers there, right?
They have to they they they have to file it, but they have to pay a subscription, very good quality buyers. And so we don't make the presumption that we know who the buyer's gonna be, because we're not smart enough. I mean the the the the market is huge. I mean it's international. So how could any one person think they know who exactly who the one the f the the perfect buyer is? In fact, one of the con concerns that we have for our for for uh business owners in general.
who get a knock on the door is you know, they get all excited and thrilled about having that knock on the door, but one buyer's not necessarily the best buyer. You want to have multiple buyers to create this uh this auction effect and to drive the price up.
Anthony Codispoti (27:12)
Why do you think it's such a good time to sell a business right now? Um I mean, historically interest rates are lower than they have been decades ago, but in recent memory they're higher than they've been. And so that's kind of got people a little put off. But what what do you think's driving it today?
Bob Scarlata (27:30)
Well to to to to mention your concern about interest rates, uh in a forty year career these interest rates are fair and reasonable. The the interest rates that we had before were artificially low. They were being driven down by the government printing money. And so we can't take that as the norm. That's that's just uh that just doesn't work. Um the I think the the
The purchase theoretically, the purchase of private companies, given the uh combination of uh of leverage and also im improvement in operations, should be able to return plus or minus 25% compounded rates of return for the buyers over time. Okay? Now, obviously, 25% comes with a risk, right? That's a hell of a lot higher than the SP 500.
S P five hundred is nine, ten percent over a hundred year history. So twenty five percent is an incredible amount more than that. Um but th I I think I think what folks are doing is they're they're uh they're chasing returns. And that's why there's so much money available to make acquisitions.
Anthony Codispoti (28:48)
Maybe taking some of the market that they would have or some of the money that they would have put in the market and put it to work in a different way, buying a business, growing that business. Yeah.
Bob Scarlata (28:55)
Absolutely. You
know, there was this story the other day about somebody creating one of the largest private family offices, twenty nine, twenty nine million dollars twenty nine billion dollars. A guy who sold his company to Cisco. Okay? So so you have these entrepreneurs selling their companies for a lot of money, and then they have to put it to work. So it's kind of a uh a cycle that's uh self supporting.
Anthony Codispoti (29:22)
Hmm. Okay, so give us the present day sound bite, Bob. What does Whitehorse Partners do today and who do you best do it for?
Bob Scarlata (29:33)
We best uh our services are geared towards the middle market private business owner. And what we do is help them successfully exit the company with the full value of their company at the t at the time of the sale. And we guide them in every step all along the way, including them finding them the best accounting people, the best MA attorneys at reasonable prices. We have a process and a procedure.
That is time tested and that works.
Anthony Codispoti (30:07)
Tell me a little bit more about the process and how early you get involved. Is the company pretty close to ready to sell by the time you're engaging with them? Or are you taking them through some cleanup processes before you take them to market?
Bob Scarlata (30:22)
No, Anthony, that's a that's a really good question. I found years ago that uh I didn't like consulting. I I I wasn't good at it, and uh it didn't produce the kind of juice that selling a company does. Uh we want to be on the same side of the table as the business owner, which is why we don't care about the upfront money very much. We we care about exiting at a very large number, getting a very nice fee for having done so.
And let the owner go off into the sunset, knowing for sure that they can take care of themselves and most likely future generations with everything they developed during their lifetime. So um we we we don't we we take our clients where we find them. And and
Anthony Codispoti (31:09)
So
Bob Scarlata (31:10)
we we tell them what their warts are, and we may leave the decision to them as to whether they want to go to market or not.
Anthony Codispoti (31:17)
Okay. So they come to you, they've got warts, you're you're very transparent about that, and then it's up to them if they want to go to market at that time or if they
Bob Scarlata (31:25)
Yeah, so
Anthony Codispoti (31:25)
want to take some time to go back and start to clean up some of those warts.
Bob Scarlata (31:31)
A hundred a hundred percent. And that's the whole purpose of the valuation, right? The valuation, we we like to say the purpose of the valuation, we're a little bit conservative in terms of valuing the company, because remember, we make our money by selling companies, not by valuing them. And so uh we we're the guys who have to go get that number if the client hires us. And so we tend to be a little bit conservative. And
we presented to the to the client. We don't really go through uh a SWOT analysis, but we'll talk about things that are at issue. Typically what's at issue is the lack of of uh precise financials. That's the biggest impediment to going to market. That's the imped and and so we'll talk to some degree about that. We have a means of fixing that as well that has been a seat change in our business, which we can talk about. But uh no.
W i i i at at it in most instances it's gonna be upwards of a year to close a deal, right? And so because it just takes that much time to make it happen. And I can I can go through the various stages that get you close to a year, how why it takes that long. Um but no, we leave it up to the client uh if that value is enough as is where is.
Anthony Codispoti (32:57)
Did I hear you say that there's been a sea change in your business?
Bob Scarlata (33:01)
Yes.
The Quality of Earnings “Sea Change”
Anthony Codispoti (33:02)
Can you say more about that, Bob?
Bob Scarlata (33:06)
Um we were we were selling a business in Lubbock, Texas, and the buyer brought in a quality of earnings team. And frankly, uh are you allowed to use semi four letter words on your podcast?
Anthony Codispoti (33:24)
Go ahead, Bob, come as you are.
Bob Scarlata (33:26)
Okay, the the uh the the financials were a shit show, okay? And but and the quality of earnings team that was hired by this buyer illustrated that. And I really liked what they did and how they did it. Our next deal was on the buy s uh on the sell side, representing a client in California uh founded by two Ukrainians who came to the United States with fifty dollars in their pocket, knew n knew no English, but
Had PhDs in refrigeration. Okay? And they started to offer refrigeration services on a very large scale, commercial uh industrial refrigeration. So they hired us to sell them. They have three sets of books, Anthony. Okay? And if you really want to know what they made, you had to look in the backyard because that's where the pool was. And so this quality of earnings team took their three sets of books.
Put them together in a way that was understandable and justifiable, and we sold that company for $24 million. Okay? That was a sea change. From there on, we require all of our sellers to get a Q of E. We believe in it so strongly that we pay for 50% of the quality of earnings cost from our fee at closing. We're putting our money where our mouth is.
What it's done is it's significantly it first of all it's made it a hell of a lot easier to negotiate the deal. It it decreases the risk from the buyer's perspective, and any time you decrease risk, you increase value. It's increased the certainty to close, and it's decreased the amount of time it takes to get to closing. It that's why I say it's a C change.
Anthony Codispoti (35:14)
Explain for our listeners what a quality of earnings report is.
Bob Scarlata (35:18)
Yes, a quality of earnings uh is a finan it's not an audit, it's a financial review, and I use review with small arc, uh lower cap R not not upper cap, that basically analyzes the financial statements in accordance with GAAP, generally accepted accounting principles. Okay? And so every buyer of any substance always does a Q of E. And let me say to you, without a doubt.
In many instances, that buyer's Q of E team is going to be made as instructed. In other words, because their fee is paid by the buyer, if there is any doubt, they're going to uh have a bias associated with the seller. So when we do the Q of E on our side, we remove that completely. That alone is worth a fortune. And when I say a fortune, I mean a fortune. It can mean a difference of
Hundreds of thousands of dollars and sometimes miljans.
Anthony Codispoti (36:21)
You know, the nature of what you do, Bob, it strikes me there's a lot of unexpected things that come up in the process. How do you guys
Bob Scarlata (36:27)
Without a doubt.
Anthony Codispoti (36:28)
how do you guys account for that?
Bob Scarlata (36:31)
Well, it's very interesting you should say that. Um when we first started getting to the middle market MA business, we attended a class uh it with a a professional organization. And I'll never forget the the the fellow was an experienced MA guy and he said, I tell all my clients that the transaction's gonna fall apart three times between the time of the LOI and closing and uh sure enough no sure enough it does.
No matter what you do, how hard you prepare, there are going to be surprises. And you just have to be agile enough, know enough people, if you will, because a good MA uh intermediary, we call ourselves intermediaries, not brokers. A good MA intermediary brings a team to to a transaction, not simply themselves. They know where to go to get answers from very highly qualified people they've worked with before.
And i one of my i I I'll never forget, we there was a big question at one point as to whether MA intermediaries like us had to be SEC li licensed. And um so uh we were requested to talk to the SEC and and after that uh when I went out on my own I decided I needed to have an attorney represent me, an SEC attorney, just in case. There was no issues
We didn't have anything to take care of. But I'll never forget I called a woman in New York City, her name is Linda Lerner. She was the highest cost attorney I'd ever uh hired in my life. $750 an hour. She has made me money, not cost me money. Okay? My point is, as we as we progress in our professions, as our businesses get more successful, I think one of the most critical
factors in future success is to hire the very best people you can possibly find in that particular niche and pay their price. And don't worry about the money 'cause it it will come out in the wash. You'll make money.
Anthony Codispoti (38:43)
Can you tell us an example of how this seven hundred and fifty dollar an hour attorney has actually made you money?
Bob Scarlata (38:49)
Yeah. In in in order in certain states we have to be SEC licensed, like California, right? And you have to have a broker. And so she knew a broker and all the brokers were charging ten percent. She went and negotiated five percent for us.
Anthony Codispoti (39:08)
That's a huge discount. Cut it in half. Yeah. So let's
Bob Scarlata (39:09)
That's a huge discount. Exactly. Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (39:13)
let's talk about your book, Bob. In two thousand twelve you published Manage to Sell Your Business, Wealth Creation Secrets of the Pros. Let's go through one of those secrets together.
Bob Scarlata (39:25)
Well, th the pros at that time I considered to be private equity groups, okay? Because they have they are very disciplined, they have uh they have a protocol for taking a business where it is and and growing it and then selling it at a higher multiple that they bought it for. So they're going to be getting uh several layers of improvements in um total price. they're gonna have paid off debt along the way.
They're going to grow the earnings of the company. They're going to make it more efficient. Uh as companies increase in value, the multiple goes up. Okay? So they get an increase in the multiple as well. And and basically in my book, that's what I talked about. I talked about uh the factors that can uh the first thing that that the first thing in my opinion relative to private equity groups is they understand value of businesses.
Business owners don't understand value. We talked about that. Well, how can you impact something? How can you affect something? How can you grow something that you don't understand the basis of? And so that to me is the is the is the uh the greatest lesson from the pros. And that's where the juice is. One, you know your value. Number two, you make your money when you exit, not along the way.
When you when you make money along the way, what's happening to that money along the way? It's being put back into the company, right? When you exit, you take it off the table.
When Selling to Employees Through an ESOP Makes Sense
Anthony Codispoti (41:05)
Another thing that Whitehorse does is design eSops, uh, which
Bob Scarlata (41:10)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (41:10)
let owners sell to their employees. Yeah, when
Bob Scarlata (41:13)
I'm glad you brought that up. Go ahead.
Anthony Codispoti (41:16)
when does it make sense to sell to your employees versus go to market?
Bob Scarlata (41:20)
Well, there needs to be sufficient critical mass in terms of the employees. There needs to be consider uh sufficient earnings from the company, and the owner has to be willing to go through the ESOP process, which is a little different than the typical sale. In many ways it's better, in some ways it's not better. But uh banks love lending to ESOPs, okay? But they're only gonna lend 50%, which means that an owner has to take back.
Promissory note of 50%. Now, the upside of selling to an ASOP, if you do it properly, is you don't pay any taxes on it. Okay? You defer the taxes until you die. Well, the earnings on the deferred taxes over a few years is worth more than the original deal. So that's and we love ESOPs.
Anthony Codispoti (42:11)
So
you're saying when the owner sells the business to the ESOP structure, the money that they're receiving back is not subject to any kind of capital gains or income tax.
Bob Scarlata (42:23)
That's correct. They can they can structure it like that. They have to do certain things. They have to make certain types of investments that the government uh mandates. It's not hard. There are ways of still taking your cash out and still preserving that tax deferral. But it it's it's there are oh my god, how many? Six thousand six thousand seven hundred ESOPs in the United States.
There are as many employees in Aesops as there are union members. Okay? Yeah, it it flies under their radar. It's the answer to inequality in the United States. Folks in Aesops can retire with seven figures. Not everybody does, obviously, but uh it's a fabulous way for employees to build wealth. In a tax
Anthony Codispoti (43:15)
When
Bob Scarlata (43:16)
in a tax deferred bet uh way, by the way.
Anthony Codispoti (43:19)
When does it not make sense? When is an Aesop not a good fit?
Bob Scarlata (43:24)
When the purchase price is significantly uh h on the private market is sufficiently higher than the the ESOP.
Anthony Codispoti (43:31)
Do you like to take a look at both situations then? Like take
Bob Scarlata (43:33)
Yes. Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (43:34)
it to market and see what are we getting here?
Bob Scarlata (43:37)
Uh w well, yes and w w i you you want to go down one path or the other. And the reason is that if if you're going down the ESOP path, you you ha you know what the value is. It's it's you're not gonna bet get a substantially above market value because it's against the law. The the the ASOP trust cannot pay higher than market value for the company it's buying. Okay? And so if you've got a company
That might have an explosive uh multiple, you don't do an ESOP. Unless the owner cares about the well-being of their of their people and wants to leave a legacy and wants to benefit all the employees that help him or her get to where they are. There's there's some of that in in doing an Aesop as well. There's a lot of that.
Anthony Codispoti (44:28)
I want to talk about something that I know is very important to you. Health and wellness. You spend a lot of time on this. I want to understand
Bob Scarlata (44:34)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (44:35)
why.
Bob Scarlata (44:36)
Yes. Yeah, um
I I have this feeling from a moral and ethical perspective that we have a responsibility to take good care of our health. I mean at a at my age I've seen the pain and suffering of folks who did not take care of their self, but ancillary to that is the care is the suffering of the caretaker to caretaker, which can can occur for years.
so unfortunately there's in among among many people there's the belief that the healthcare system's gonna take care of you. N I mean that's you know, that's like the two greatest lies, right? You know, we're from the government and we're here to help you. Um because the healthcare system maybe, but it's such a it's such a uh uh a a slow of the uh a throw of the dice. Folks need to spend money.
on on paying for their own health. I want to tell you, we're s we believe in this so strongly that when we sell a a a client business, we pay for an executive physical for them of world class proportions at fifty five hundred dollars at our expense. We we we we know a concierge doctor's practice here in Nashville. We're we're a patient there, we're an investor and we're also on the board. That's not why we send our clients there. We send our clients there because they do such a superb job.
And um that's how much we believe in health and wellness. We we we we use our own money to support that. And so far we've had close to twenty people that we've said through that program.
Anthony Codispoti (46:24)
And so you guys aren't just in it for the money. You know, you guys have closed the transaction and you're taking money out of your pocket to make sure that this person who's just had this life-changing uh fiscal event take place in their in their lives, they've got the the health and the longevity to be able to enjoy it.
Bob Scarlata (46:43)
If they follow the the if they follow the it's a hundred page report and if they f if they follow the recommendations, it can make a huge difference. In this large transaction we closed, during the course of the transaction, the gentleman was telling me about his brother who had a heart attack, and he started telling me about his um about his family history and I said, Look, here's what what I did. He goes and does it.
Which basically is C T angiogram followed by an AI interpretation called clearly of that C T angiogram, finds out he has four um blockages of seventy percent, sees an interventionist, finds two more, one's at ninety percent, has some stints put in, and he basically says, I was he was sixty seven years old. I was a walking time bomb. I could have died tomorrow.
So yeah, no, I believe and and and here he is with this wealth now that and he can do all this good, but he died because he d because he just didn't know about his own health. I mean what a tragedy that is.
Hardest Challenge: Bad Partners and Resilience
Anthony Codispoti (47:58)
Story. Thank you for sharing that. What's one of the hardest things, Bob, that you've had to go through? And what did going through that teach you?
Bob Scarlata (48:08)
I would say having bad partners and believing them.
Anthony Codispoti (48:12)
Let's
hear more about that, whatever you're comfortable saying.
Bob Scarlata (48:14)
Well, um, yeah, I mean i th you know, if if you're active in the marketplace, you're gonna meet people and there are gonna be suggestions as to partnerships. Partnerships are very difficult. In many ways I I think they're more difficult than marriages. Um and and and I uh there have been times and I I'm I'm typical of many entrepreneurs who've been close to bankruptcy. You know, when you've got the bankruptcy attorneys in your Rolodex, that that's not a good sign, okay?
And and so yeah, there've been hard times, but you just bear down and you get through it.
Anthony Codispoti (48:49)
Say more about the bearing down and getting through it though. Because I think this is the part that sort of gets glossed over in a lot of stories, right? Like people are like, yeah, it was hard, but I got through it. And then when somebody else goes through a hard thing, they're like, why am I not getting through this? Why do I feel stuck? Why is this so hard? Other people just seem to roll on. And they only think that because they don't have uh visibility into other people's struggles, other people's sufferings. So, what was it like for you to get through those times?
Bob Scarlata (49:19)
That's a very good question. I found a guy out of uh Harvard, I think his name is Ackerman or Ackman, and he had four daily uh steps that one could take to to improve and one's resilience. And and one of them was uh a a list of gratitudes. What am I thankful for today? And it it sounds it sounds so I I I don't know, hoity toity or uh
ethereal, but I don't think it is. I think uh I think the act of gratitude for who and what we are, including our good health, including the loved ones around us, I think that's very significant. Um and and so that's how I got through it. I'd every day I would do the same thing and uh a little meditation, exercise. I think exercise is if it were a prescription drug, it would be the number one selling drug
By untold margins. Exercise is so critical. And it's not easy. It's hard to do good exercise that makes a difference. Does that answer the question?
Anthony Codispoti (50:29)
So I hear meditation, I hear
exercising, and I hear daily gratitude. I love it. It's a good
Bob Scarlata (50:34)
Yeah. Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (50:36)
recipe.
Bob Scarlata (50:37)
Well and and i i it it worked. It it helped me get through it.
Anthony Codispoti (50:44)
Are you guys using AI in your work, Bob?
Bob Scarlata (50:46)
We are. Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (50:48)
How so?
Bob Scarlata (50:51)
Well, I I pretty well have it open on my screen all the time, uh, to a to ask questions of something that I uh that I that I'd like to know more about. Uh we're using it to help draft our our books, our valuation uh book. We're doing it to help draft the uh confidential information memorandum that we put together, to do market research. Uh we use it in a number of different aspects.
Anthony Codispoti (51:21)
You mentioned the book earlier, whether it's a book or a pamphlet or however it kind of ends up coming out, the related to the risk of owning a a middle market business. What's what's the inspiration here? Why why do you feel called to write a book about this?
Bob Scarlata (51:38)
Um
I think about the black swan events that have have have occurred during my lifetime. Of course the latest one being COVID. A lot of folks had very successful businesses during co d before COVID that were destroyed by COVID. And it had nothing to do with them. It just occurred. ah
of our lives and of our businesses a fool's errand. It's not true. We don't have control. So uh the c the question becomes what's enough? Okay? And that's i it a a question for every individual to answer. But I think enough in many instances is a lot less than people think they need to do what they want to do the rest of their lives. And by the way, most of the transactions we do
The business owner stays on. They often stay on a retained equity position. So they continue in their same position. They continue to own a percentage of the company and have significant upside, and they took chips off the table, and their family is secure. And um that is very having that sense of security, having enough money in the lockbox, I think is very important because it gives you a sense of freedom y you you you didn't have before.
I th and I think that's a big deal. Because remember, we we got a letter, we got an email from one business owner whose business we sold down in Texas, and he said an email, thank you very much for your help. I had no idea how much stress I was under while managing the company.
Anthony Codispoti (53:31)
Yeah, you just get used to a sort of a new baseline and until you take away all the factors that were contributing to it, you yeah, you you don't know. You're like, my gosh, this is what it feels like to not be constantly stressed and on guard.
Bob Scarlata (53:45)
A a hundred percent. And business owners, rightfully so, uh and I'm I'm an example. Think about their business twenty four seven. They may not be writing stuff down, but it's there, it's a presence, always.
Anthony Codispoti (54:00)
I've talked to a lot of business owners who have written books related to the industry that they're involved in. And I'm always
Bob Scarlata (54:06)
Yes.
Anthony Codispoti (54:06)
curious to understand if it was just a fun project or was it a fun project that also helped to grow the business in some way.
Bob Scarlata (54:18)
Yeah. Um for me the book didn't help me grow the business at all. Okay. Uh fun project, I would say I would say it's like a a therapy session in in in palpable form in book form. Because it it really is therapeutic to put your thoughts down on paper and to have a final product that shows it. And it it's it's it's really rewarding for the self as opposed to others.
I I don't know if I have anything valuable to say to other people. That's not for me to determine, it's for others to determine. But uh I feel compelled with respect to some of these messages because of what I see in the daily practice of my business.
Will AI Replace M&A Advisors?
Anthony Codispoti (55:04)
I want to go back to AI because it's a hot topic. Everybody wants to talk about AI. Some people are very excited about it. Some people feel threatened. It's the end of the world. I'm
Bob Scarlata (55:14)
Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (55:15)
curious how you view it long term as it pertains to your line of work. Do you see it as this is the thing that is going to allow us to serve more people more efficiently in a better way? Do you see that maybe there's a risk somewhere down the road that this replaces?
what you do. That I could just go to an AI tool and hey, I'm ready to sell my business. Take me through the process. Click.
Bob Scarlata (55:43)
Well, there's certainly that concern that that you mentioned. However, I'm old school, okay? I I believe in face to face visits, face to face discussions. I believe in using the phone. Um that's not necessarily true of current generation. They wanted to do text messages and emails. And um I don't think there's any substitu substitution for judgment. Now maybe AI will develop such a great
judgment that that you won't need humans. I I have no idea. That's beyond my expertise. But I I can promise you getting our clients through these transactions and buyers as well is very much based upon personality, character, uh resilience. I mentioned earlier that the deals fall apart three times between now and closing. Well somebody's gotta pick up the pieces and put Humpty Dumpty back together again.
It's gonna be a human and the and they're gonna have been there before, maybe with a new twist, but nevertheless they'll have ideas as to how that might happen. So I I kind of I you know how how many how many times have we had issues in our lifetime uh and beyond that were potentially catast catastrophic? I mean, I was raised when the atom bomb was a huge concern.
During school, as you probably know, we used to have exercises where you went under the desk if there was a uh an atomic alarm. I mean, can you imagine an eight year old going under their desk because they're fearful of an atomic bomb landing? How ridiculous that is. You know, um yeah, uh who knows? I I I I think we we we have to make the best with what we have at the moment.
Anthony Codispoti (57:36)
Hmm. As you think about the work that you're doing now, Bob, what is it that you most want to be remembered for?
Bob Scarlata (57:45)
Oh, Anthony, I I don't know. I I again I think that's a little bit of a fool's errand. You know, I think to d not that I'm a Bible quoter, but you know, we're uh dust to dust is what I believe. I don't think I'll be remembered past ten minutes after I die.
Anthony Codispoti (58:05)
Really?
Bob Scarlata (58:07)
Well I
Anthony Codispoti (58:09)
Is that just being
is that just modesty coming through or
Bob Scarlata (58:12)
No, it's it's uh I I th life goes on. And so yeah, I mean I'm I'm here, I'm maybe I'm making a difference, maybe I'm not. But you do the very best you can and you look at continuous improvement and curiosity. That to me, I mean no matter what happens, whether we close a deal or not, that that perseverance, that curiosity, that that's what's sustaining. The money's a great reward, but but the act
The process is what really counts.
Anthony Codispoti (58:47)
What's one rule in business that you would never break, no matter what?
Bob Scarlata (58:50)
Don't run out of cash.
Anthony Codispoti (58:53)
I like it. Very basic.
Bob Scarlata (58:58)
You run out of cash, baby? You're out of business. Yeah.
Anthony Codispoti (59:02)
Good advice. Uh,
Bob, before I ask my last question here for you, I want to do three quick things for the audience. First of all, anybody who wants to get in touch with Bob Scarlata, go to his website, which is whitehorse-partners.com. We'll put that in the show notes, but again, it's whitehorse-partners.com. And if you're enjoying the show today, please take a moment to subscribe wherever you're listening.
It also sends a signal that helps others discover our podcast. So thanks for taking a quick moment to spread the word. And if you advise business owners that are heading toward an exit, here's a lever most of your clients don't know they have: a program that counterintuitively turns their healthcare plan into higher net profits, increasing the value of a business and raising the price a buyer will pay. It's backed by Bain Capital Insurance, so you can recommend it with confidence.
Bring your clients that kind of win and they'll pass your name along. AddBackBenefits.com. So last question for you today, Bob. A year from now, what is one very specific thing that you hope to be celebrating?
Bob Scarlata (1:00:11)
Being above ground and healthy?
Anthony Codispoti (1:00:16)
Very basic. Again, I love it. Like let's get just down to the Yeah, without that you've got
Bob Scarlata (1:00:16)
And and you know
Anthony Codispoti (1:00:21)
nothing else.
Bob Scarlata (1:00:22)
you know, I find myself as I get older uh needing and wanting friendships to a greater degree. And and having a close group of of people that I'm associated with, that I can go hiking with, that I can have conversations with. That's something indeed to celebrate.
Anthony Codispoti (1:00:43)
I love that. Bob Scarlata from White Horse Partners. I want to be the first to thank you for sharing both your time and your story with us today. I appreciate you being here.
Bob Scarlata (1:00:52)
Thank you, Anthony. It's been fabulous being with you as well.
Anthony Codispoti (1:00:55)
Hey folks, that's a wrap on another episode of the Inspired Stories Podcast. Thanks for learning with us. And if one thing stood out, put that into action today.
Connect with Bob Scarlata:
Website: whitehorse-partners.com




